who, whom, whose, which, that, where, why — defining vs non-defining.
A relative clause is a subordinate clause that describes a noun in the main clause. The noun it describes is the antecedent, also called the head noun. The clause cannot stand alone: it needs a main clause to complete the sentence.
The book that I bought yesterday was expensive. The main clause is "The book was expensive". The relative clause "that I bought yesterday" tells us which book.
Every relative clause carries its own verb. If the whole sentence has only one verb, it has no relative clause.
A defining clause identifies which person or thing we mean. Remove it and the sentence loses its point. There are no commas.
A non-defining clause adds extra information about something already identified. Remove it and the sentence still stands. It sits between commas, and it rejects that.
In a defining clause, a pronoun that is the object of the clause can be left out. A pronoun that is the subject cannot.
It is not a question and it is not a noun clause. "What he said surprised me" is a noun clause, because what carries its own antecedent inside it. A relative clause always has its antecedent outside the clause.
Antecedent + relative word + (subject) + verb + rest of clause
The relative word holds a grammatical slot inside the clause. Name that slot first, then pick the word. That single step solves most exam items.
The verb of the relative clause agrees with the antecedent.
Two forms are correct; register decides which one you write.
A defining clause in the active voice can shrink to a present participle; in the passive voice, to a past participle.
The tree below takes one sentence apart: The book that I bought yesterday was expensive. Read it from the top down. The noun phrase on the left holds the head noun book and the relative clause that modifies it; the verb phrase on the right is the main predicate.
What the tree shows:
Defining, no commas: The students who failed the test must retake it. Only some students failed.
Non-defining, two commas: The students, who failed the test, must retake it. All of them failed.
Nothing in the words changed. The commas moved the clause from a restricting branch to a commenting branch, and the meaning of the sentence changed with them.
The office in which she works has the same structure, with one extra layer: in which is a preposition plus its object, and the whole phrase is the place adverbial. where replaces that whole phrase in one word, which is why where and in which are interchangeable here.
The teacher who taught us chemistry retired last year.
Two verbs: taught and retired. The relative clause is "who taught us chemistry". who is the subject of taught, and the antecedent the teacher is a person. Person plus subject gives who; that is also possible; which is not.
The colleague with whom I share an office is Egyptian.
whom follows with, and the phrase "with whom" works as an adverbial inside the clause. Formal writing keeps the preposition in front. The neutral version is "The colleague (who) I share an office with is Egyptian". Never "with who".
The girl whose bag was stolen cried.
whose bag is the subject of was stolen. whose replaces a possessive adjective and takes the noun directly, with no article: whose bag, not "whose the bag". The test: if the clause would otherwise contain her, his, their or its, use whose.
The train which leaves at seven is always crowded.
Antecedent the train is a thing; the slot is the subject of leaves. So which or that. Because which is the subject it cannot be deleted: "The train leaves at seven is always crowded" is wrong.
Alexandria is the city where I grew up.
where equals in which. The clause "I grew up" is already complete, so it needs an adverbial, not an object. Compare the error "the city where I visited": visited needs an object, so that sentence must be "the city (which) I visited".
I still remember the day when we first met.
when equals on which. The antecedent is a time noun such as day, year, moment or morning. If the clause already carries its own time adverbial, drop the relative word: "the day we met in Cairo".
The reason why he left is still unclear.
why equals for which and appears almost only after reason. Three forms are correct: "the reason why he left", "the reason that he left", and "the reason he left". Do not attach why to other nouns; for other nouns use a preposition phrase, as in "the cause of his departure".
Defining: The students who failed the test must retake it. Only the failing students retake it.
Non-defining: The students, who failed the test, must retake it. All of them failed and all retake it.
The words are identical; the commas change the population. In speech the defining clause runs on without a pause, and the non-defining clause drops in pitch and sits between two pauses.
The book (which / that) I bought yesterday was expensive.
Inside the clause, bought already has a subject (I) and needs an object. which fills that object slot, so it may be deleted. The slot then stays empty: "the book I bought it" repeats the object and is wrong.
He arrived two hours late, which annoyed the teacher.
Here which points at no single noun; it points at the fact "he arrived two hours late". This use is always non-defining, always after a comma, and never that.
The students, most of whom were tired, left early.
most of whom means "most of the students". For things, use most of which: "The books, most of which were old, sold quickly". that cannot follow a preposition, so "most of that" is impossible.
| Antecedent | Slot in the clause | Defining | Non-defining |
|---|---|---|---|
| person | subject | who / that | who |
| person | object | whom / who / that / nothing | whom / who |
| person | possessive | whose + noun | whose + noun |
| thing or animal | subject | which / that | which |
| thing or animal | object | which / that / nothing | which |
| place | adverbial | where / in which | where / in which |
| time | adverbial | when / that / nothing | when |
| reason | adverbial | why / that / nothing | why |
| whole clause | - | not used | which |
| Feature | Defining | Non-defining |
|---|---|---|
| Commas | none | two, one on each side |
| that | allowed | not allowed |
| Object pronoun omitted | allowed | not allowed |
| Job of the clause | identifies which one | adds a comment |
| Can it be removed? | no, the sentence stops making sense | yes, the sentence still stands |
| Speech | no pause | pause, and a drop in pitch |
| Typical subjects | common nouns: a book, the man, any city | proper nouns and unique nouns: Cairo, my father, this book |
| Form | Function | Example | Test |
|---|---|---|---|
| who | person, subject of the clause | the man who called | replace with he: he called |
| whom | person, object of the clause | the man whom I called | replace with him: I called him |
| whose | possession, person or thing | the man whose car was stolen | replace with his: his car |
| who is / who has | contracted to who is or who has | the man who is waiting | expand it: who is waiting, not a possession |
| of which | possession, things only | the house the roof of which is red | formal variant of whose roof |
| Adverb | Full form | Antecedent type | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| where | in / at / on which | place: city, house, office, stage | the office where I work |
| when | in / on / at which | time: day, year, moment, morning | the year when we met |
| why | for which | reason only | the reason why he left |
One trap sits under Table 4. The adverb replaces a whole preposition phrase, so the clause must not need an object: "the city where I visited" fails because visited is transitive. The version with a preposition and which copies the same logic: the city in which I live is correct, the city in which I visited is not.
| Mistake | Why it is wrong | Correction |
|---|---|---|
| My brother, that lives in Cairo, is a doctor. | that is banned in non-defining clauses | My brother, who lives in Cairo, is a doctor. |
| The man which helped me was kind. | which never refers to a person | The man who helped me was kind. |
| The girl who’s bag was stolen cried. | who’s means who is, so it cannot show possession | The girl whose bag was stolen cried. |
| The book I bought it yesterday was expensive. | the object slot is already filled by the relative word, so it stays empty | The book I bought yesterday was expensive. |
| The city where I visited was beautiful. | where replaces an adverbial, but visited needs an object | The city which I visited was beautiful. |
| This is the house which I was born. | born needs in, and the preposition cannot vanish | This is the house where I was born. |
| The people who lives next door are noisy. | the clause verb agrees with the antecedent, not with who | The people who live next door are noisy. |
| I have a friend who he works in Dubai. | the subject appears twice: who and he | I have a friend who works in Dubai. |
| She is the only one of the girls who have finished. | here who refers to the only one, which is singular | She is the only one of the girls who has finished. |
| All what I need is a pen. | what already contains its antecedent, so all has nothing to attach to | All that I need is a pen. Or: What I need is a pen. |
| The man to whom I spoke to was polite. | the preposition appears twice | The man to whom I spoke was polite. |
First, always write the comma pair before you choose the word: the punctuation decides the options. Second, when two answers look possible, prefer the one that keeps the clause grammatical without the relative word. If the clause stands alone as a sentence, the relative word is an object and the answer may be omitted.
Cover the relative word in any sentence you read today and ask two questions: does the clause still have a subject, and does it still have an object if the verb needs one? A yes to both means the word was an object and could be deleted. A no means the word was a subject and had to stay.
Free · three languages · works offline